Skip to Main Content

Four clinics across Lancaster, Chester, and York County

No referral needed for most insurances in Pennsylvania*

Conditions

Scaphoid Fracture

Also called: Broken scaphoid, Navicular fracture of the wrist

A therapist working on a patient's arm and shoulder

The scaphoid is a small bone on the thumb side of your wrist. It is the most commonly fractured of the eight small wrist bones, and it is the one most likely to cause trouble.

There is one thing worth knowing above all else: scaphoid fractures are frequently missed on initial X-rays, and a missed scaphoid fracture can lead to permanent problems. Persistent pain on the thumb side of the wrist after a fall deserves proper assessment even if you were told the X-ray was clear.

Why this bone is different

The scaphoid has an unusual blood supply. Blood enters mostly at one end and flows back toward the other, so the part furthest from that entry point depends entirely on blood passing through the rest of the bone.

When the bone breaks across the middle or near the far end, that supply can be cut off. The fragment then has little or no blood reaching it.

Two consequences follow. Fractures may fail to heal, which is called nonunion. And the bone fragment can die from lack of blood supply, called avascular necrosis. Both lead to wrist arthritis over time if not addressed.

That is why this small bone gets so much attention.

Why it gets missed

Scaphoid fractures often do not show on X-rays taken immediately after the injury. The fracture line can be too fine to see until some bone resorption occurs around it, which takes a week or two.

Meanwhile the wrist may not look dramatic. There is often no obvious deformity, swelling can be modest, and people frequently assume they have sprained it and carry on.

The result is that people are reassured by a normal X-ray, go away, and return months later with a nonunion that is far harder to treat.

Signs you might have one

  • Pain on the thumb side of the wrist after a fall onto an outstretched hand
  • Tenderness in the anatomical snuffbox, the small hollow at the base of the thumb when you extend it
  • Pain gripping or pinching
  • Pain when pushing the thumb toward the wrist
  • Swelling, often mild
  • Reduced wrist movement

Snuffbox tenderness after a fall is the classic sign, and it is the one that should prompt further assessment regardless of what the first X-ray showed.

How it is treated

Suspected fracture with normal X-ray. Usually immobilized and reassessed, often with a repeat X-ray after ten to fourteen days, or with MRI or CT which detect it earlier.

Undisplaced fracture. Cast immobilization, often for six to twelve weeks. Longer than most fractures, because of the blood supply problem.

Displaced fracture, or fracture near the far end. Surgery, usually a screw, because of the high risk of nonunion.

Nonunion. More complex surgery, often involving a bone graft.

Some surgeons now fix even undisplaced fractures in active people, to avoid months in a cast.

How physical therapy helps

  • Maintaining movement in the fingers, elbow and shoulder throughout immobilization
  • Restoring wrist and forearm range once cleared, particularly rotation
  • Progressive grip and wrist strengthening
  • Swelling and scar management
  • Graded return to work, sport and manual tasks
  • Monitoring, since ongoing pain after a supposedly healed scaphoid warrants reassessment

Recovery here is slower than most wrist injuries, and the immobilization period is longer, so stiffness is usually more pronounced.

What treatment looks like at Neff

The same doctor every visit, working within your surgeon's protocol.

If you come to us with thumb-side wrist pain after a fall and have not had a scaphoid fracture properly excluded, we will send you for imaging before treating you as a sprain. Given the consequences of missing one, that is the right order.

Common questions

  • My X-ray was clear but it still hurts. What now?

    Get it reassessed. Scaphoid fractures commonly do not appear on the first X-ray. A repeat X-ray after ten to fourteen days, or an MRI or CT, is the usual next step for persistent snuffbox tenderness.

  • Why is the cast on for so long?

    Because of the blood supply. The scaphoid heals more slowly and less reliably than most bones, so immobilization periods are longer, sometimes twelve weeks or more.

  • What happens if it does not heal?

    A nonunion usually leads to abnormal wrist mechanics and eventually arthritis. It can be treated surgically, often with a bone graft, but results are better the earlier it is addressed.

  • Should I have surgery instead of a cast?

    For displaced fractures, generally yes. For undisplaced fractures it is a genuine discussion. Surgery avoids months in a cast, which matters for some people's work and sport. Your surgeon will advise.

  • How long until I can go back to manual work or contact sport?

    Usually not until the fracture is confirmed healed, which can be three months or more. Returning early risks nonunion, and that is a much bigger problem than the wait.

What we'll work on together

Your therapist will take the time to understand more than just the injury. How you move, what your day actually asks of you, and what "back to normal" means for you specifically. Getting back to farming is a different goal from getting back to a half marathon, and your plan should say so.

For Scaphoid Fracture, that usually means working through:

  • Settling the pain down enough that you can move and sleep
  • Getting your movement back, in the directions you've lost
  • Rebuilding strength properly, progressed week by week
  • Fixing what caused it, which is often somewhere other than where it hurts
  • Getting you back to it, at a pace that holds rather than one that flares

The hands-on and exercise work we'd likely use here: active range of motion, joint mobilization, isotonic exercise, soft tissue mobilization.

The goal isn't just getting you out of pain. It's leaving you stronger than the problem found you, so it doesn't keep coming back.

Who treats this at Neff

Dr. Adam Soltys (Oxford), Dr. Dan Neff (Willow Street), Dr. Kristopher Davis (Quarryville), Dr. Ross Drawbaugh (York)

Let's get you moving again

You don't need a doctor's referral to get started. In Pennsylvania we can evaluate you and begin treatment straight away, so you're not sitting on a waiting list for a physician appointment before anyone even looks at the problem.

Some insurance plans still want a referral on file before they'll cover treatment. Give us a call and we'll check your plan with you, so there are no surprises later.

And you'll see the same doctor every visit. Your Doctor of Physical Therapy leads every appointment, and you get hands-on treatment every time. It's how physical therapy is supposed to work.

Find the clinic closest to you

Quarryville

203 Commerce Dr
Quarryville, PA 17566

(717) 786-1245

Oxford

46 S 3rd Street
Oxford, PA 19363

(484) 756-8603

Willow Street

5 E Wynwood Dr
Willow Street, PA 17584

(717) 464-7000

York

1689 Kenneth Rd
York, PA 17408

(717) 850-2777

Request an appointment online and we'll call you back to get you scheduled, usually the same working day.

Still not sure we're the right fit? Call and ask. We'd genuinely rather point you toward the right person than book you an appointment you don't need.

Related conditions

Treatments mentioned on this page

Related service


This page is general health information, not medical advice. It cannot tell you what is causing your pain. For that you need someone to examine you in person. If your symptoms are severe, getting worse, or following an injury, talk to a doctor or a physical therapist.

Ready when you are

No referral needed for most insurances in Pennsylvania. We will check your insurance with you before you commit to anything.

Request an appointment