Skip to Main Content

Four clinics across Lancaster, Chester, and York County

No referral needed for most insurances in Pennsylvania*

Conditions

Shoulder Instability

Also called: Loose shoulder, Shoulder subluxation

A therapist working on a patient's arm and shoulder

Shoulder instability means the ball of the shoulder does not stay properly centered in its socket. That can range from a feeling that the shoulder might give way, through partial slipping, to full dislocation.

The single most useful question is how it started, because traumatic and atraumatic instability are almost different conditions and they are treated very differently.

Why the shoulder is built this way

The shoulder trades stability for movement. The socket is shallow, roughly the size of a golf tee holding a golf ball, which is what lets your arm reach in so many directions.

Stability comes from three sources: the labrum, a rim of cartilage deepening the socket; the ligaments and capsule surrounding the joint; and the muscles, particularly the rotator cuff and the muscles controlling the shoulder blade.

The muscles are the part you can change. That is why rehabilitation works even when the passive structures are stretched or damaged.

The two very different types

Traumatic instability. Started with a specific injury, usually a dislocation. Typically unstable in one direction, most often forwards. Often involves damage to the labrum or the socket rim. More common in younger athletes and in contact sport.

Atraumatic instability. No injury. The shoulder has always been loose, often both shoulders, and often other joints too. Usually unstable in more than one direction. See multidirectional instability.

The distinction drives everything. Traumatic instability in a young contact athlete has a high recurrence rate and surgery is discussed early. Atraumatic instability responds well to rehabilitation and surgery is generally avoided.

Signs and symptoms

  • A sense that the shoulder is about to slip out, particularly with the arm raised and rotated back
  • Actual slipping or clunking
  • Pain with overhead or throwing movements
  • Aching after use
  • Avoiding certain positions without consciously deciding to
  • Weakness or a dead arm feeling
  • With significant instability, episodes of full dislocation

Apprehension, meaning a distinct feeling of dread when the arm is put in a vulnerable position, is one of the more telling signs.

How physical therapy helps

Muscular control can compensate a great deal for loose passive structures.

  • Rotator cuff strengthening, which centers the ball in the socket
  • Shoulder blade strengthening and control, since the blade is the platform the arm works from and it is very commonly the weak link
  • Proprioception training, rebuilding the shoulder's sense of where it is in space
  • Progressive loading into the positions you need, including overhead and behind the body
  • Sport-specific retraining for throwing, swimming or contact sport
  • Avoiding provocative positions early, then reintroducing them deliberately

For atraumatic instability, a properly delivered rehabilitation program is the treatment of choice and has good outcomes. It takes months rather than weeks, and consistency matters.

What treatment looks like at Neff

The same doctor every visit. The first appointment establishes which type you have, tests the direction of instability, checks for general joint hypermobility, and assesses cuff and shoulder blade strength.

If you are a young athlete with recurrent traumatic dislocations, we will tell you honestly that a surgical opinion is worth having, because recurrence rates in that group are high.

How long it takes

Atraumatic instability programs typically run three to six months. Improvement is gradual and strength-dependent, and stopping early is the usual reason it does not hold.

Traumatic instability managed without surgery follows a similar timeline, with return to contact sport guided by strength and control rather than dates.

Common questions

  • Is a loose shoulder something I was born with?

    Sometimes. Some people have naturally more elastic connective tissue, which affects several joints. That is atraumatic instability, and it responds well to strengthening.

  • Will my shoulder keep dislocating?

    It depends heavily on age and activity. Recurrence is common in young athletes after a traumatic first dislocation and much less likely in older adults. Rehabilitation reduces the risk in every group.

  • Do I need surgery?

    Not usually for atraumatic instability, where rehabilitation is the preferred treatment. Surgery is considered more readily for recurrent traumatic instability, particularly in young contact athletes.

  • Can I lift weights?

    Yes, with guidance. Some positions, particularly wide-grip overhead and behind-the-neck movements, place the shoulder in vulnerable positions and are usually modified. Strengthening is part of the solution rather than something to avoid.

  • Why does my shoulder ache after use even without slipping?

    Because the muscles are working harder than they should to keep the joint centered. That fatigue ache is common and usually improves as strength and control build.

What we'll work on together

Your therapist will take the time to understand more than just the injury. How you move, what your day actually asks of you, and what "back to normal" means for you specifically. Getting back to farming is a different goal from getting back to a half marathon, and your plan should say so.

For Shoulder Instability, that usually means working through:

  • Settling the pain down enough that you can move and sleep
  • Getting your movement back, in the directions you've lost
  • Rebuilding strength properly, progressed week by week
  • Fixing what caused it, which is often somewhere other than where it hurts
  • Getting you back to it, at a pace that holds rather than one that flares

The hands-on and exercise work we'd likely use here: balance and proprioception training, isometric exercise, isotonic exercise, pnf (proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation), active range of motion.

The goal isn't just getting you out of pain. It's leaving you stronger than the problem found you, so it doesn't keep coming back.

Who treats this at Neff

Dr. Adam Soltys (Oxford), Dr. Dan Neff (Willow Street), Dr. Kristopher Davis (Quarryville), Dr. Ross Drawbaugh (York)

Let's get you moving again

You don't need a doctor's referral to get started. In Pennsylvania we can evaluate you and begin treatment straight away, so you're not sitting on a waiting list for a physician appointment before anyone even looks at the problem.

Some insurance plans still want a referral on file before they'll cover treatment. Give us a call and we'll check your plan with you, so there are no surprises later.

And you'll see the same doctor every visit. Your Doctor of Physical Therapy leads every appointment, and you get hands-on treatment every time. It's how physical therapy is supposed to work.

Find the clinic closest to you

Quarryville

203 Commerce Dr
Quarryville, PA 17566

(717) 786-1245

Oxford

46 S 3rd Street
Oxford, PA 19363

(484) 756-8603

Willow Street

5 E Wynwood Dr
Willow Street, PA 17584

(717) 464-7000

York

1689 Kenneth Rd
York, PA 17408

(717) 850-2777

Request an appointment online and we'll call you back to get you scheduled, usually the same working day.

Still not sure we're the right fit? Call and ask. We'd genuinely rather point you toward the right person than book you an appointment you don't need.

Related conditions

Treatments mentioned on this page

Related service


This page is general health information, not medical advice. It cannot tell you what is causing your pain. For that you need someone to examine you in person. If your symptoms are severe, getting worse, or following an injury, talk to a doctor or a physical therapist.

Ready when you are

No referral needed for most insurances in Pennsylvania. We will check your insurance with you before you commit to anything.

Request an appointment